Zac Lee, Development 1(New Species),
Digital Print, 48in x 48in, 2010
Nirmala Karuppiah, Dancers, Silver Gelatin Ed. 8
by Shalini Ganendra
The thrust of exceptional and notable contemporary art – the world over, is creation of works that through their formation, presentation and/or purpose – captivate, educate and are memorable. Certainly one art market development in the last 20 years is that there is less distinctions between local and international are less, as artists, like all other professionals, participate in globalization and have to distinguish themselves in that mire of competition. Art has become hugely commercial, academic and demanding. Demarcation of high art and merchandising is also blurred.
Malaysia‟s art world has been busy too – developing ideas, artists, public institutions, collectors and patronage. During the last 20 years, the new location for the National Art Gallery opened, very visibly on Jalan Tun Razak. The Gallery has hosted a number of exhibitions and continues to focus on presenting Malaysian art history through programs and curated shows. “NAG”, as it is familiarly called , has launched a newsletter this year, Senikini, which comments and informs on art happenings. The NAG website is a resource for exhibitions, awards and events.
Galeri Petronas opened in 1993 at the Dayabumi Complex and in 1998 moved to the elegant and hi-tech space in the KLCC. The gallery boasts 2000 sq. meters of sleek, circular space.
The Islamic Arts Museum opened in 1999. Its establishment also marked a significant development for the Malaysian art scene because of its international stature and collection. Though not a venue for Malaysian fine arts per se, the museum has contributed to the perception of Kuala Lumpur as a growing cultural centre.
Both the Islamic Art Museum and the National Art Gallery have strong conservation departments, with the much needed expertise to repair damage from the humidity, poor storage and other tropical delights.
With all these attractions, are these institutions drawing in more visitors? A senior artist comments that despite the existence of stronger art venues, visitor numbers have not increased significantly. This is not entirely true. Local visitors now have more to see in KL, and there appears to be increasing traffic at these institutions for specific purposes.
Note also that, Museum visits are not the only way to learn about local art movements (though this writer maintains such visits are crucial for gaining aesthetic insight into local art in local contexts). By setting up physical presences along with active electronic and hardcopy supports – these institutions are participating in the development of the local art scene in a positive and necessary way.
One way to gauge the impact of exhibitions is to read some entries on the numerous blogs and websites that have been launched. Kakiseni, established over ten years ago, was the first site to cover the local happenings including art exhibitions. Last year, Time Out Malaysia , ARTERI and What’s Art set up websites.
Local art fairs and social „ art activities‟ are another measure of KL‟s growing importance as a viable art center. 2007 saw the launch of Art Expo Malaysia, now an
annual event. Galeri Shah Alam held the first Mail Art Festival in Malaysia earlier this year. Kuala Lumpur Design Week 2009 drew in a number of interesting entries with sculpted functional art and design collaborations. Charities and NGOs more regularly raise funds through art auctions and exhibitions.
On the international front, Malaysian artists have been featured in Art Fairs and exhibitions in the USA, UK, Europe, the Middle East, Hong Kong, Beijing, Australia and Singapore.
International Auction houses invested in Malaysia some years back. Sotheby‟s and Christie‟s, particularly, have helped to create interest in art from Asia. Armed with strong PR departments, extensive collector bases, and sturdy reputations – the auction houses provide artists with a short cut to financial success if their works are auctioned well. The houses give collectors peace of mind on provenance and, to a some extent, quality. Sotheby‟s opened a representative office in KL in 1994 and Christie‟s, in 1997. Christie‟s first auctioned Malaysian Artists in 1994 and Sotheby‟s, in 1996.
Mok Kim Chuan, Sotheby‟s Head of Southeast Asian Paintings, comments:
“Origins of collectors of Sotheby’s Southeast Asian Art on a whole have become more international in recent years. Apart from the collectors from Southeast Asian region itself or Southeast Asian expatriates residing in other countries, we are also attracting more collecting from other parts of Asia, as well as from the West. We are seeing more collectors “crossing over” from other categories.”
Ms Ruoh-Ling Keong, Vice President & Head of Southeast Asian Modern and Contemporary Art at Christie‟s, expresses a slightly different view:
“Malaysian modern and contemporary art is characterized by a relatively strong domestic market with a handful of major collectors who enjoy close relationship with artists. At this moment, the majority of Malaysian art and artists are not generally known outside of Malaysia and Singapore, let alone the region of Asia. ….Recently emerging from the increasing cross-exposure of Asian art through art fairs and auction sales, we have seen the works of contemporary artists … gaining attention in the auction market from collectors outside of Malaysia.”
With regard to the identity of buyers of Malaysian art at auction, Keong observes:
“ Major collectors of Malaysian modern and contemporary art at auction are Malaysians. It's a reflection of the character of the art market and a support to their nation artists. The works of Malaysian artists that were auctioned at Christie's mostly have a comparatively matured primary market.”
Auction houses constantly re-evaluate markets and marketing, looking for the next „big area‟. The areas selected need to be sustainable and well managed to maintain credibility. As noted, part of that responsibility falls on local participation. Artists and clients who enter works into auction should be aware that there is the risk of the work not selling after such wide exposure – a consequence that does not help the artist or work.
And when art markets tumble, as they did this year, even the auction houses are severely punished, showing the unfavourable consequences of speculation. Collectors who purchased high (and sometimes questionable quality), now cannot sell. Some have been badly affected – including once prosperous international galleries and dealers who have closed their doors. Hence the comparison of the art markets to stock markets, with the increasing comodification, manipulation, speculation and fraud, common to both.
But not everyone plays auction, nor is inclined to do so. A vital component of any growing art scene is local and individual participation. The websites and blogs, coverage by magazines, television, radio and other media (local and international), along with the growing sophistication of artists and commercial galleries, provides ample information and product. Additionally, newer mediums are being explored and mediums traditionally not considered fine art, e.g. photography, are now more mainstream than every.
New galleries and art advisors are surfacing regularly with exhibitions and projects featuring old and developing talents. There are a growing number of underground movements, not to mention graffiti art. All these activities now have to stand up to the scrutiny of a more informed public.
With this onslaught of information and activity – there is a greater need, (certainly more than there was 20 years ago), to be wary. Audiences should be thorough and discerning when processing this abundance of information. Intuition and time will tell which are the most credible sources, presenting worthy content and advice.
Established artists who have observed and participated in the development of the last two decades provide constructive commentary. Award winning artist Yeoh Kean Thai observes:
“Audiences nowadays are more aware about art but most still lack the critical appreciation of art. Most are still looking for pictures to decorate walls. Collectors still buy what is supposed to be a good investment, but sadly most of them are getting bad advice from some galleries concerned only with selling their goods.”
A similar sentiment is voiced by established artist and theorist, Nasir Baharuddin:
“Collectors are more impressed with commodity rather than inculcating the culture of an art world and its understanding. I need art collectors who bother to understand rather than who just buy work.”
In a New York Times Article on Handling Art (9/6/09), a storage company CEO quipped: “Some Malaysian collectors rent entire apartments just to store their artworks.” What an indication of growth! Be warned though, overconsumption is an indication of over-speculation. There will be many a white elephant left in these storage quarters. So, let us not ask: “ Is yours bigger than mine?” - when the real question should be: “Is yours better?”
We know some collectors are collecting A LOT more, but are there really more collectors? Some artists are doubtful, commenting “ Yes, we do see more individuals parting with 4 to 5 figure amounts to purchase artworks but are there more collectors? ”
This writer asserts there are. Different galleries have varying collector bases, though there is some overlap. By and large, audiences are now disparate and not predictable. The number of artists have increased as well, fueled by growing economic viability of the vocation and a host of art schools providing affordable and costly fine art and design degrees.
The first local art colleges were UiTM and MPIK, both funded by government and established in the early 70's, with western influenced and traditional art. The first private art college was MIA which focused on western art development and Chinese painting. Now, there are numerous private colleges and public universities with art programs. There are also a growing number of art fellowships/residencies hosted by private and public entities, locally and internationally. Malaysian artists are winning international awards. Zac Lee, Yeoh Kean Thai, Nirmala Karrupiah have each won the Freeman Fellowship to Vermont Studios (USA) which tends to jump start artistic careers. Yeoh Kean Thai went on to win a prestigious Commonwealth Art Residency Award 2009 in a highly competitive run up.
In so far as collectors‟ motivations for buying - these continue to be disparate the world over -though there is an increasing emphasis on „investment‟ value. Some buy for decoration, some for social statement, others for investment – some for all of the above. Most reasons may be legitimate – but each come with varying levels of risk.
Regardless of motivations, we must applaud the developments of the last two decades, in the Malaysian art scene. This writer‟s wish for the next 20 years, is to see an increase in museum quality works by artists and in private and public collections, with the corresponding growth in awareness that what we create, collect and endorse should be WORLD CLASS. Nothing less.
©All rights reserved.
Malaysia‟s art world has been busy too – developing ideas, artists, public institutions, collectors and patronage. During the last 20 years, the new location for the National Art Gallery opened, very visibly on Jalan Tun Razak. The Gallery has hosted a number of exhibitions and continues to focus on presenting Malaysian art history through programs and curated shows. “NAG”, as it is familiarly called , has launched a newsletter this year, Senikini, which comments and informs on art happenings. The NAG website is a resource for exhibitions, awards and events.
Galeri Petronas opened in 1993 at the Dayabumi Complex and in 1998 moved to the elegant and hi-tech space in the KLCC. The gallery boasts 2000 sq. meters of sleek, circular space.
The Islamic Arts Museum opened in 1999. Its establishment also marked a significant development for the Malaysian art scene because of its international stature and collection. Though not a venue for Malaysian fine arts per se, the museum has contributed to the perception of Kuala Lumpur as a growing cultural centre.
Both the Islamic Art Museum and the National Art Gallery have strong conservation departments, with the much needed expertise to repair damage from the humidity, poor storage and other tropical delights.
With all these attractions, are these institutions drawing in more visitors? A senior artist comments that despite the existence of stronger art venues, visitor numbers have not increased significantly. This is not entirely true. Local visitors now have more to see in KL, and there appears to be increasing traffic at these institutions for specific purposes.
Note also that, Museum visits are not the only way to learn about local art movements (though this writer maintains such visits are crucial for gaining aesthetic insight into local art in local contexts). By setting up physical presences along with active electronic and hardcopy supports – these institutions are participating in the development of the local art scene in a positive and necessary way.
One way to gauge the impact of exhibitions is to read some entries on the numerous blogs and websites that have been launched. Kakiseni, established over ten years ago, was the first site to cover the local happenings including art exhibitions. Last year, Time Out Malaysia , ARTERI and What’s Art set up websites.
Local art fairs and social „ art activities‟ are another measure of KL‟s growing importance as a viable art center. 2007 saw the launch of Art Expo Malaysia, now an
annual event. Galeri Shah Alam held the first Mail Art Festival in Malaysia earlier this year. Kuala Lumpur Design Week 2009 drew in a number of interesting entries with sculpted functional art and design collaborations. Charities and NGOs more regularly raise funds through art auctions and exhibitions.
On the international front, Malaysian artists have been featured in Art Fairs and exhibitions in the USA, UK, Europe, the Middle East, Hong Kong, Beijing, Australia and Singapore.
International Auction houses invested in Malaysia some years back. Sotheby‟s and Christie‟s, particularly, have helped to create interest in art from Asia. Armed with strong PR departments, extensive collector bases, and sturdy reputations – the auction houses provide artists with a short cut to financial success if their works are auctioned well. The houses give collectors peace of mind on provenance and, to a some extent, quality. Sotheby‟s opened a representative office in KL in 1994 and Christie‟s, in 1997. Christie‟s first auctioned Malaysian Artists in 1994 and Sotheby‟s, in 1996.
Mok Kim Chuan, Sotheby‟s Head of Southeast Asian Paintings, comments:
“Origins of collectors of Sotheby’s Southeast Asian Art on a whole have become more international in recent years. Apart from the collectors from Southeast Asian region itself or Southeast Asian expatriates residing in other countries, we are also attracting more collecting from other parts of Asia, as well as from the West. We are seeing more collectors “crossing over” from other categories.”
Ms Ruoh-Ling Keong, Vice President & Head of Southeast Asian Modern and Contemporary Art at Christie‟s, expresses a slightly different view:
“Malaysian modern and contemporary art is characterized by a relatively strong domestic market with a handful of major collectors who enjoy close relationship with artists. At this moment, the majority of Malaysian art and artists are not generally known outside of Malaysia and Singapore, let alone the region of Asia. ….Recently emerging from the increasing cross-exposure of Asian art through art fairs and auction sales, we have seen the works of contemporary artists … gaining attention in the auction market from collectors outside of Malaysia.”
With regard to the identity of buyers of Malaysian art at auction, Keong observes:
“ Major collectors of Malaysian modern and contemporary art at auction are Malaysians. It's a reflection of the character of the art market and a support to their nation artists. The works of Malaysian artists that were auctioned at Christie's mostly have a comparatively matured primary market.”
Auction houses constantly re-evaluate markets and marketing, looking for the next „big area‟. The areas selected need to be sustainable and well managed to maintain credibility. As noted, part of that responsibility falls on local participation. Artists and clients who enter works into auction should be aware that there is the risk of the work not selling after such wide exposure – a consequence that does not help the artist or work.
And when art markets tumble, as they did this year, even the auction houses are severely punished, showing the unfavourable consequences of speculation. Collectors who purchased high (and sometimes questionable quality), now cannot sell. Some have been badly affected – including once prosperous international galleries and dealers who have closed their doors. Hence the comparison of the art markets to stock markets, with the increasing comodification, manipulation, speculation and fraud, common to both.
But not everyone plays auction, nor is inclined to do so. A vital component of any growing art scene is local and individual participation. The websites and blogs, coverage by magazines, television, radio and other media (local and international), along with the growing sophistication of artists and commercial galleries, provides ample information and product. Additionally, newer mediums are being explored and mediums traditionally not considered fine art, e.g. photography, are now more mainstream than every.
New galleries and art advisors are surfacing regularly with exhibitions and projects featuring old and developing talents. There are a growing number of underground movements, not to mention graffiti art. All these activities now have to stand up to the scrutiny of a more informed public.
With this onslaught of information and activity – there is a greater need, (certainly more than there was 20 years ago), to be wary. Audiences should be thorough and discerning when processing this abundance of information. Intuition and time will tell which are the most credible sources, presenting worthy content and advice.
Established artists who have observed and participated in the development of the last two decades provide constructive commentary. Award winning artist Yeoh Kean Thai observes:
“Audiences nowadays are more aware about art but most still lack the critical appreciation of art. Most are still looking for pictures to decorate walls. Collectors still buy what is supposed to be a good investment, but sadly most of them are getting bad advice from some galleries concerned only with selling their goods.”
A similar sentiment is voiced by established artist and theorist, Nasir Baharuddin:
“Collectors are more impressed with commodity rather than inculcating the culture of an art world and its understanding. I need art collectors who bother to understand rather than who just buy work.”
In a New York Times Article on Handling Art (9/6/09), a storage company CEO quipped: “Some Malaysian collectors rent entire apartments just to store their artworks.” What an indication of growth! Be warned though, overconsumption is an indication of over-speculation. There will be many a white elephant left in these storage quarters. So, let us not ask: “ Is yours bigger than mine?” - when the real question should be: “Is yours better?”
We know some collectors are collecting A LOT more, but are there really more collectors? Some artists are doubtful, commenting “ Yes, we do see more individuals parting with 4 to 5 figure amounts to purchase artworks but are there more collectors? ”
This writer asserts there are. Different galleries have varying collector bases, though there is some overlap. By and large, audiences are now disparate and not predictable. The number of artists have increased as well, fueled by growing economic viability of the vocation and a host of art schools providing affordable and costly fine art and design degrees.
The first local art colleges were UiTM and MPIK, both funded by government and established in the early 70's, with western influenced and traditional art. The first private art college was MIA which focused on western art development and Chinese painting. Now, there are numerous private colleges and public universities with art programs. There are also a growing number of art fellowships/residencies hosted by private and public entities, locally and internationally. Malaysian artists are winning international awards. Zac Lee, Yeoh Kean Thai, Nirmala Karrupiah have each won the Freeman Fellowship to Vermont Studios (USA) which tends to jump start artistic careers. Yeoh Kean Thai went on to win a prestigious Commonwealth Art Residency Award 2009 in a highly competitive run up.
In so far as collectors‟ motivations for buying - these continue to be disparate the world over -though there is an increasing emphasis on „investment‟ value. Some buy for decoration, some for social statement, others for investment – some for all of the above. Most reasons may be legitimate – but each come with varying levels of risk.
Regardless of motivations, we must applaud the developments of the last two decades, in the Malaysian art scene. This writer‟s wish for the next 20 years, is to see an increase in museum quality works by artists and in private and public collections, with the corresponding growth in awareness that what we create, collect and endorse should be WORLD CLASS. Nothing less.
©All rights reserved.
Shalini Ganendra menulis
ReplyDelete....
A similar sentiment is voiced by established artist and theorist, Nasir Baharuddin:
“Collectors are more impressed with commodity rather than inculcating the culture of an art world and its understanding. I need art collectors who bother to understand rather than who just buy work.”
...
Boleh saudara panjangkan sedikit apa maksud saudara yang sebenar...saya bersetuju terhadap terhadap kenyataan seseorang kolektor itu perlu mamahami potensi karya yang akan dibelinya terlebih dahulu sebelum dijadiakn sebagai koleksi?
ha...maksudnya kalau nak membeli baju, mestilah tahu apa jenisnya. sizenya berapa, kualiti baju bagaimana, untuk siapa, anakke atau emaknya, dan berbagai lagi. walaupun kita beli baju tu sebagai hadiah.
ReplyDeletejadi kolektor bukan setakat beli je...mereka perlu bijak dan memahami karya yang sebagaimana akan membawa potensi yang hebat pada masa hadapan.
bukan setakat orang kumpul karya kita pun kumpul. memang tak dinafi setiap pembelian akan ada tujuannya. mungkin untuk didagangkan atau mungkin sebagai hobi dan bahan dekorasi. tapi adalah lebih baik para pengumpul seni bertindak dalam memahami setiap apa yang dibelinya supaya, kerja-kera yang dikumpul oleh mereka akan menjadi koleksi/khazanah dan sebagai bahan kajian masa akan datang. dan pelukis juga harus memahami kenapa karya yang dibuatnya itu penting. bukan juga setakat untuk mendapat wang.
namun fungsi kolektor ini penting kerana mereka adalah penyimpan khazanah seni dan akan mengembangkan lagi hasil seni. kalau koleksinya baik maka eloklah data/maklumatnya untuk dikaji dan jadi bahan rujukan.
almaklum